Best Cigar Ashtray of 2020: Complete Reviews with Comparisons

This site contains affiliate links to products. We may receive a commission for purchases made through these links.

One of the constants of smoking cigars is that you’ll always have to deal with the ash. This isn’t much of a problem if you’re smoking outside, but it can leave quite a mess unless you have an ashtray to use.

Ashtrays come in many shapes and sizes but choosing one that will suit your needs will always increase your enjoyment while smoking.

In this article, we’ll review some of the best cigar ashtray options on the market to help you make an informed choice.

Comparison Chart

Mantello Cigars – Large Premium Black Ceramic Cigar Ashtray for for Indoor, Outdoor, Patio, Home, Office Use – Cigar Accessories Gift Set for Men and Women
Prestige Import Group – Triangular Maple Lacquer 3 Cigar Ashtray – Dark Maple Wood and Black Accents
CiTree Cigar Ashtray, Cigar Travel Ashtray, Metal Ashtray (Silver)
GALINER Cigar Ashtray, Portable Metal Cigar Travel Ashtray (Yellow)
The Big Easy Tobacco Co., Quad Table Cigar Cutter, Brushed Finish, For 52 and 60 Ring Gauge

Best Cigar Ashtray Reviews

Mantello Cigars Ashtray

Ideal for those who like smoking their cigars outside, the Mantello Cigars Cigar Ashtray is a perfect addition to a smoker’s patio or terrace.

Review

With a cobalt blue color, meant to enhance its design, this ceramic cigar ashtray is a great accessory for those who like smoking outdoors. With a long groove meant to hold longer cigars, this solidly built and durable ashtray will surely last you for quite some time.

The pricing is also a great advantage of the Mantello Cigars Cigar Ashtray. This is an accessory that is sure to be within the budget of even beginners to the hobby.

A bit of a nitpick though is that the padding underneath is situated at the center of the ashtray. This means that out of the box it tends to wobble. This is quickly fixed by placing pads at the sides, but quite why it was designed that way is a mystery.

Smokers of smaller cigars may also find it a bit inconvenient that they always have to move the cigar closer as they smoke. This disadvantage is more of a matter of taste in cigars rather than the fault of the ashtray. Overall, this is a product that’s great for those who want a quality ashtray at an affordable price.

Pros

  • Holds full-length cigars
  • Solidly built
  • Quite affordable

Cons

  • Wobbles because of padding
  • Smaller cigars need frequent moving

Prestige Import Group – Triangular Maple Lacquer 3 Cigar Ashtray

Perfect for the social smoker, the Prestige Import Group Triangular Maple Lacquer 3 Cigar Ashtray is sure to be a conversation starter.

Review

If you’re looking for an ashtray that you can put on your tabletop and that looks elegant without breaking your budget, this may be the right choice for you. Made to hold three cigars at a time, with a lacquered dark maple wood finish, this is sure to enhance your smoking room. Take note that the finish isn’t suited for outdoor use and may get damaged if exposed to harsh weather.

Although the ash catcher is deep enough to hold a cigar’s worth of ashes, it may be a bit small to hold three. This is easily remedied as the tray is magnetic and can simply be removed for easy cleaning.

This ashtray is made to have a bit of additional weight. And its sturdy construction ensures that it won’t slide around while it’s on the top of your table. All in all, it’s a great ashtray for those who often have people over for a smoke.

Pros

  • Easily removable ash catcher
  • Great looking design
  • Won’t slide around

Cons

  • Not suited for outdoor use
  • Tray can be a bit small

CiTree Cigar Ashtray

An ashtray made for the smoker on the go, the CiTree Cigar Ashtray is a must-have for those that like to smoke while traveling.

Review

If you’re looking for a solidly built and durable ashtray, the CiTree Cigar Ashtray should be on your radar. Add to the fact that you can easily take it along with you on your travels, and any cigar aficionado will love having this accessory in their collection.

This portability is further enhanced by the nonslip bottom design that allows it to be placed securely on top of various surfaces. This ensures that you always have a secure place to get rid of your ash wherever you smoke.

Made out of solid aluminum, this ashtray is guaranteed to be durable. This solid construction along with its corrosion-resistant nature ensures that you’ll get a lot of enjoyment from using this ashtray.

The CiTree Cigar Ashtray is remarkably easy to clean. A quick wipe with a cloth will remove any stray ash. You can also pop it into a dishwasher if you want as its certified dishwasher safe.

The only real nitpick that one can have is that the ashtray is a bit small — a disadvantage of its portable nature. It may not be able to handle full-length cigars, and the ash catcher may need frequent emptying. Other than that, this is a great ashtray for both beginners and aficionados alike.

Pros

  • Portable
  • Nonslip design
  • Durable
  • Easy to clean

Cons

Can be a bit small

GALINER Cigar Ashtray

A perfect portable ashtray for the beginner hobbyist, the GALINER Cigar Ashtray is a handy accessory at a relatively affordable price.

Review

Made with portability in mind, the GALINER Cigar Ashtray is solidly constructed out of solid aluminum. This means that not only is this ashtray very durable, it’s also corrosion, and impact resistant. Paired with a relatively affordable price, it’s amazing value for money.

This ashtray was designed to be quite easy to clean but the underside prevents it from being dishwasher safe. The material at the bottom prevents this ashtray from sliding around while protecting surfaces from scratching and abrasions. The underside does tend to wear out, so care should be taken from exposing it to the elements.

As with most portable ashtrays, it can be a bit too small for those who like to smoke lengthier cigars. Still, at the relatively affordable price, it’s a great accessory for those looking to expand their collection of smoking paraphernalia.

Pros

  • Very portable
  • Great Price
  • Durable construction
  • Slide-proof bottom
  • Easy to clean

Cons

  • A bit small
  • The bottom can wear out quickly

The Big Easy Tobacco Accessories Square Grid Cigar Ashtray

Surely an ashtray meant for the aficionado, the Big Easy Tobacco Accessories Square Grid Cigar Ashtray is a piece that will always draw attention.

Review

With its rather unique grid design and elegant appearance, the Big Easy Tobacco Accessories Square Grid Cigar Ashtray was designed by cigar aficionados for cigar aficionados.

It’s sure to become a great conversation starter whenever smokers congregate. The grid is made to hold up to 60 ring gauge cigars with ease, allowing smokers of all varieties of cigars to use it. The ash catcher is designed to resist horizontal wind, which makes this ashtray perfect for the outdoors. A smokers’ terrace or patio will surely be enhanced by having this around.

However, the well is a bit hard to clean, but as it can hold the ashes of multiple cigars rather easily it doesn’t need frequent cleaning. It’s also slightly on the expensive side, but with the quality offered, it’s still a great accessory to have.

Pros

  • Great conversation piece
  • Heavy construction
  • Can hold up to 60 gauge cigars
  • Holds ashes well
  • Usable Outdoors

Cons

  • Hard to clean
  • A bit pricey

Buyer’s Guide

There’s more to an ashtray than just the ability to hold ashes. With the multitude of designs and models, all offering great options, it can get overwhelming when choosing one to buy. Here, we will provide a few things that you may want to keep in mind whenever you’re buying an ashtray to ensure that you’re getting the best value.

Place of Use

Indoor and outdoor ashtrays are built differently. Although most outdoor ashtrays can just as easily be brought inside, the same can’t be said for indoor types. Most outdoor ashtrays also feature deeper ash catchers to prevent the wind from blowing ashes all over the place. This can make them rather bulky, which could prove problematic if they’re brought indoors.

There’s also the chance that outdoor type ashtrays can easily scuff table and countertops. These ashtrays were built to be rugged, so don’t usually keep the surfaces that they’re put on in mind.

If you want to gift an ashtray to a friend or for yourself, consider the place where they usually smoke. This will determine the kind of ashtray that you may want to buy.

Portability

For those who like to smoke while on the go, getting portable ashtrays is a good idea. A thing to keep in mind though is that most portable ashtrays tend to be smaller. This is obviously to make it easier to transport them. The downside is that a lot of lengthy cigars won’t be able to rest easily on a small ashtray.

If you smoke cigars like Churchill’s, which are longer than most, then it may be better to get a tabletop ashtray or find a portable one that was specifically made to handle long cigars.

Ease of Cleaning

Cigar ashes are messy and cleaning them can be rather inconvenient. Getting an ashtray that’s simple to clean makes it easier for the smoker to continue their hobby without worry. Some cigar ashtrays are built to handle a lot of ashes, making cleaning infrequent, but nothing beats something you can easily wipe clean.

Some ashtrays are certified to be dishwasher safe. These types are certainly on the top of the list when it comes to ease of cleaning. The ability to just put your ashtray in a dishwasher to get all that gunk out is a great advantage. Just make sure that there aren’t any ashes left on the inside or you may risk damaging your dishwasher in the process.

Price

Of course, an important thing to consider when getting a cigar ashtray is the price. For beginners to the hobby, it’s usually better to invest in more types of cigars rather than gear. Even for aficionados, spending too much on an ashtray can be an eyebrow-raiser. Always balance the quality with the price to ensure that you can get an ashtray that’s worth the money.

Taking Care of Your Ashtray

No matter the price of your ashtray, making sure that it’s well taken care of ensures prolonged use and enjoyment.

Empty the Ash Catcher When You’re Done

For those that have deeper ash catchers, this may be a bit inconvenient, as it seems a waste to empty it when it doesn’t necessarily need to be emptied. Keeping your ashtray clean prolongs its lifespan. Ashes left in the catcher, especially those in the outdoors, can stick to the tray. Wait longer, and this may build up and cause damage to the tray itself. Remember that ashes aren’t the only thing that can find its way to your ashtray. Empty them regularly.

Make Sure to Use Ashtrays as Intended

Some inattentive smokers are often surprised when they find their expensive ashtray damaged by the elements. Know the type of ashtray that you’re using and use it as the manufacturer intended. Indoor ashtrays may last a day or two outside, but they will deteriorate quickly.

Get More Than One Ashtray

Though not exactly a way to take care of the ashtray, getting multiple pieces does increase their collective lifespan. The more you use an ashtray, the more they break over time. Having several around ensures that you can use them alternately and ease up on the wear and tear.

Final Verdict

The clear winner of the best cigar ashtray for 2020 is the CigTree Cigar Ashtray. The price, portability, and ease of cleaning present in this model undoubtedly make it a great choice. Its durable construction ensures that you’re getting the best value for your money and long years of enjoyment. It may be a bit small for those that smoke longer cigars, but if normal ones are your cigar of choice, this ashtray is surely a great deal.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Special offer for our visitors

Get your Cigar Free Guide

We will never send you spam. By signing up for this you agree with our privacy policy and to receive regular updates via email in regards to industry news and promotions